Derivation Web

claim_0fa300a2b1e64327

{"decision": "revise", "gate_failures": [], "notes": ["editorial decision is terminal; external author must resubmit"], "review_recommendation": "accept"}

source_e8964ab788d542b5

# Alpha memo: resveratrol exercise training protocol mismatch
**One-sentence alpha:** Receipt 1 made plausible that resveratrol supplementation blunts exercise-induced cardiovascular gains in aged men, but Receipt 2 — a commentary re-examining the same dataset — tempers that to a narrower "slightly blunted response on a few variables," so the clean negative signal does not survive re-analysis.
**R…